The 2025 appeal figures by area of law
| Area of law | Judgments | Median | Middle half | No award |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial leases | 1,576 | €2,000 | €1,500 to €3,000 | 38% |
| Residential leases | 2,645 | €1,000 | €800 to €2,000 | 41% |
| Co-ownership | 1,159 | €2,000 | €1,500 to €3,000 | 26% |
| Construction | 2,179 | €2,000 | €1,500 to €3,000 | 37% |
| Company disputes | 652 | €3,000 | €2,000 to €4,000 | 40% |
| Commercial contracts | 2,923 | €2,500 | €1,500 to €3,500 | 29% |
Median and middle half: calculated on judgments awarding a sum only. No award: share of judgments where the court rules that article 700 does not apply or dismisses the claim.
Differences between areas of law are marked: the median sum ranges from €1,000 in residential leases to €3,000 in company disputes. Figures for each court of appeal appear in the tool above, for the 34 courts with at least 30 judgments.
First instance and appeal
Before the judicial court, the barometer separates judgments on the merits, which decide the dispute, from interim relief orders. Under article 484 of the Code of Civil Procedure, an interim relief order is a provisional decision, made by a judge who is not hearing the main case, to order the necessary measures immediately.
| Court | Decisions | Median | Middle half | No award |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Courts of appeal | 11,134 | €2,000 | €1,500 to €3,000 | 35% |
| Judicial courts, judgments on the merits | 17,163 | €1,200 | €800 to €2,000 | 17% |
| Judicial courts, interim relief orders | 12,219 | €1,200 | €1,000 to €1,500 | 36% |
Median and middle half: calculated on decisions awarding a sum only.
The median sum awarded on the merits by the judicial courts (€1,200) is lower than that of the courts of appeal (€2,000). In interim relief, it is €1,200.
| Area of law | Court of appeal | Judicial court, merits | Judicial court, interim relief |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial leases | €2,000 | €2,000 | €1,200 |
| Residential leases | €1,000 | €2,000 | €1,000 |
| Co-ownership | €2,000 | €1,000 | €1,500 |
| Construction | €2,000 | €2,000 | €1,500 |
| Company disputes | €3,000 | €2,000 | €1,500 |
| Commercial contracts | €2,500 | €1,000 | €1,200 |
A dot means fewer than 30 decisions: no figure is published.
What article 700 provides
Under article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, the court orders the party liable for costs, or the losing party, to pay the other party the sum it determines for expenses incurred and not included in recoverable court costs. These expenses are mainly lawyers' fees.
- A sum set by the court. The text sets no scale and no cap: the court decides the amount.
- Two criteria. The court takes into account fairness or the financial position of the party ordered to pay.
- No award possible. On the same grounds, the court may decide, even of its own motion, that no sum is due.
- Supporting documents. The parties may produce evidence of the sums they claim, such as invoices and fee agreements.
In the operative part of their judgments, courts of appeal often rule both on the sum set by the first instance court and on the expenses incurred on appeal. The barometer only records the sum awarded for the appeal.
Court costs and article 700: two separate items
Recoverable court costs are a closed list set by article 695 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Under article 696, the losing party bears them, unless the court, giving reasons, puts all or part of them on another party.
| Expense | Court costs (article 695) | Article 700 |
|---|---|---|
| Fees and charges collected by court registries | Yes | No |
| Fees of technical experts, including court-appointed experts | Yes | No |
| Fees of public officers, including bailiffs | Yes | No |
| Regulated lawyers' fees, including pleading fees | Yes | No |
| Lawyers' fees agreed freely with the client | No | Yes |
| Other expenses outside court costs: travel, a technical adviser chosen by the party | No | Yes |
Method and limits
- Source. Decisions of the judicial courts and judgments of the courts of appeal published by the French Supreme Court on Judilibre, queried through its API, under the open licence 2.0 and the reuse conditions for court decisions.
- Scope. Decisions delivered in 2025 falling within one of the six areas in the table. The area of law is the code of the French civil case nomenclature assigned to the case: commercial leases (30), companies and other groupings (34 to 36), residential and professional leases (51), construction works (54), services and other contracts (56 and 59), unfair competition and abrupt termination (39H and 39J), co-ownership (71 and 72).
- Reading. Only the operative part of the decision is read. A sum is recorded only where a single provision awards an amount under article 700 or for unrecoverable costs, for a single amount; the frequent dismissal of the other party's claim makes no difference. On appeal, provisions confirming or varying the first instance judgment are set aside.
- Cases set aside. Joint and several awards, sums awarded to each of several parties, awards also covering the first instance and unrecognised wording are set aside rather than guessed: 4,983 appeal judgments in 2025 and 8,247 first instance decisions.
- First instance. Interim relief orders are identified from their heading or the name of the chamber: they form a separate series. Orders of the pre-trial judge, which deal with procedural issues, and decisions of the enforcement judge are set aside. Decisions of the commercial courts are not included: Judilibre assigns them no area of law code.
- Check. 200 judgments drawn at random from those read automatically were reviewed one by one on 22 November 2026: 8 errors, an error rate of 4%. 200 first instance decisions were reviewed the same way on 22 November 2026: 3 errors, an error rate of 1.5%. Each series is only published if this rate is 5% or less.
- Small numbers. No figure is published for an area, a court or a combination with fewer than 30 decisions.
- No statistics by chamber, judge or lawyer. The barometer only breaks figures down by area of law and court. Article L. 111-13 of the Code of Judicial Organisation prohibits any reuse of the identity data of judges and court clerks whose purpose or effect is to assess, analyse, compare or predict their professional practices.
- No personal data. Decisions are read during collection and are not stored. Only aggregated figures are published.
- Updates. Once a year, in the first quarter, for the decisions of the previous year.
The aggregated figures can be downloaded as a CSV file under an open licence: download the data. Please cite “Judilibre, French Supreme Court, processing by Miraï Avocats”.
