Skip to content
MIRAÏAvocats

Commercial Law

Online defamation lawyer in France: removal and compensation

Fake reviews, disparagement or defamation aimed at your business in France: we get the content taken down and claim compensation for the harm.

Call
Contents

A false review, a smear campaign, a few malicious posts: online, damage to a business’s reputation is fast, visible and lasting. French law offers effective remedies, but you must choose the right legal category and act quickly, because the time limit for going to court depends on the nature of the statements. Online content has no fixed location, and the firm, based in Paris, acts for clients throughout France.

Maître Léa Scemama, an online reputation lawyer in Paris, helps businesses and their executives stop wrongful content, have it removed and obtain compensation. She also plans the response with you, because a clumsy reaction can make things worse. She works in English, and files can be handled remotely by video call and electronic signature, so a company based abroad does not need to come to Paris.

All our work for businesses is listed on our commercial law page.

Instructing the firm on an online reputation matter

Your online reputation matter with the firm, at a glance
Your matterWhat the firm provides
Getting startedA first response within 24 working hours, then a first conversation, by video call if you are abroad, to classify the statements (disparagement, defamation, fake review) and work out the time limit for acting, which can be as short as three months.
FeesDepending on the stage, from the notice to the platform to court proceedings, with an indicative range from €1,500 excluding VAT for a matter (fee schedule). The breakdown by stage is in the costs table. A fee agreement is signed before any work starts.
TimescaleIn practice, a few days to a few weeks for a notice to the platform. For defamation, proceedings must be brought within three months.
Outside ParisOnline content has no fixed location: the firm acts for clients throughout France and abroad. Outside the area of the Paris Court of Appeal, a local lawyer goes on the record where the law requires it (Law of 31 December 1971, article 5). The firm remains your point of contact.
Follow-upOne point of contact, Maître Léa Scemama, with an update in English at each stage: evidence, notice, formal demand, proceedings.

How we protect your reputation online

How we protect your reputation online
WhenWhat we doWhat you get
You discover the contentClassifying the statements and working out how much time is left to actThe legal basis to use and the deadline not to miss
EvidenceReport by a judicial officer, time-stamped screenshots, measuring how widely the content has spreadEvidence that survives even if the content is deleted
TakedownNotice to the platform in the required form, formal notice to the authorRemoval, or a reasoned refusal that opens the next step
UrgencyUrgent interim proceedings for removal and, where appropriate, to identify the authorA fast court decision
CompensationClaim for disparagement, defamation or unfair competitionA damages claim on the right legal basis

How we bill is explained on our fees page.

Your online reputation is a business asset

A company’s online reputation now shapes how far customers, partners and job applicants trust it. A disparaging article that ranks well, a fake review at the top of the results or a rumour shared on social media can drive customers away and hurt turnover for a long time. The answer is not only a matter of communication: it is often a legal matter too.

Your situation: what we do

How the firm responds, situation by situation
Your situationWhat we doLegal basis
Fake Google review or false reviewA report by a judicial officer, a reasoned notice to the platform, then identifying the author and taking action if neededArticle 1240 of the Civil Code; Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, article 16
Disparagement by a competitorEvidence of the campaign, a formal demand, a claim for disparagement or unfair competition and a claim for compensationArticles 1240 and 1241 of the Civil Code; five years to act
Defamatory content (article, post, video)Precise classification of the statements, a removal notice and, within three months, a defamation claimLaw of 29 July 1881, articles 29, 53 and 65
Content that must come down urgentlyUrgent interim proceedings for removal and, where needed, to identify the authorDepends on how the statements are classified

Disparagement or defamation: why the difference matters

Everything starts with classifying the statements, because that decides the legal basis, the procedure and the time limit for acting.

Disparagement and defamation under French law: legal basis and time limit
DisparagementDefamation
What it coversPublicly discrediting a business's products, services or activityHarming a person's honour or reputation by alleging a specific fact
Legal basisGeneral civil liability, articles 1240 and 1241 of the Civil Code, often linked to unfair competitionLaw of 29 July 1881 on freedom of the press
Formal requirementsThe ordinary rulesStrict
Limitation periodFive yearsThree months

Getting the classification wrong can make the claim fail, so it is the first point the firm checks.

Fake and abusive reviews

Online reviews are a particularly sensitive area. A dissatisfied customer is entitled to give a negative opinion in good faith. But the author is liable for a false review, a fake review posted by a competitor or a former employee, or criticism that goes too far and unfairly discredits the business. The courts accept that publishing fake reviews that harm a business causes a loss that must be compensated under article 1240 of the Civil Code.

French consumer law also regulates the reviews themselves. Anyone whose business involves collecting, moderating or publishing online consumer reviews must give fair, clear and transparent information on how reviews are published and processed, and say whether they are checked (article L. 111-7-2 of the Consumer Code). Publishing fake consumer reviews, or commissioning them, is a commercial practice deemed misleading (article L. 121-4, 28°).

When the reviews come from a campaign run by a competitor, an unfair competition claim can be added: see our unfair competition and liability page.

Getting a review or disparaging content removed

Several tools are available, and they can be combined depending on how urgent the situation is and what you want to achieve. A report to the platform or host, under the law on illegal content, can lead to removal without going to court. A formal notice to the author, if known, settles many situations. And where the harm is obvious, urgent interim proceedings can quickly obtain removal of the content and, where appropriate, the identification of its author.

Notifying the platform. Since February 2024, the EU Digital Services Act has replaced the previous system. The biggest change is practical: you no longer need to contact the author of the content first, a step that wasted valuable time and alerted the author. The notice goes straight to the platform.

A valid notice includes the following.

What a notice to the platform must contain
What to includeWhy
A reasoned explanation of why the content is illegalThis is what triggers the platform's duty to deal with the notice
The exact URL of the content, and anything else that helps locate itA vague notice is rejected
The name and email address of the person sending the noticeExcept for certain criminal offences listed in the Regulation
A statement, made in good faith, that the information is accurateIt is mandatory

The platform must then explain its decision, whether or not it removes the content, and offer an internal complaints procedure to challenge it. A refusal is no longer an unexplained dead end: it is in writing, reasoned and open to challenge.

These rules are set out in articles 16 and 17 of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 of 19 October 2022, which has applied since 17 February 2024. Article 20 provides for the internal complaints procedure, and article 21 for referral to a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body. A notice that allows a diligent hosting provider to see that the content is illegal without a detailed legal examination gives the provider actual knowledge of it (article 16(3)). The provider must then act promptly to remove the content or disable access to it; otherwise it loses the liability exemption under article 6.

Claiming compensation for the damage

Beyond removal, the business can claim compensation for its financial and non-financial loss. When the statements come from a competitor, the claim falls under unfair competition and may form part of wider commercial litigation. The firm gathers the evidence needed to prove fault and put a figure on the loss: reports by a judicial officer, time-stamped screenshots and an analysis of how widely the content spread.

Costs and timeframes of an online reputation case

Indicative figures for ordinary disparaging or defamatory content. The route depends first on how the statements are classified, which also sets the time limit for acting.

Cost and timeframe of each step
StepCosts to expectRealistic timeframeOur fees
Takedown notice to the platformNoneThe platform must handle the notice in a timely, diligent, non-arbitrary and objective manner (article 16(6) of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065); in practice, a few days to a few weeks€500 to €800 excluding VAT
Formal notice to the authorNone, apart from registered postThe time given to the author, in practice 8 to 15 daysTime spent, at €300 excluding VAT per hour
Application to identify the author, or urgent interim proceedingsA judicial officer’s report recording the content; service of documents by a judicial officerIn practice, a few weeks. For defamation, proceedings must be brought within three months (article 65 of the Law of 29 July 1881)€1,500 to €3,000 excluding VAT
Claim on the meritsSummons served by a judicial officer; for defamation, the writ must set out and classify the statements precisely and state the applicable provision (article 53 of the Law of 29 July 1881)Disparagement: five years to act (article 2224 of the Civil Code); in practice, 8 to 15 months at first instanceFrom €2,500 excluding VAT

The losing party pays the court costs (article 696 of the Code of Civil Procedure), and the court may order it to pay you a sum towards your other expenses, including legal fees (article 700).

Documents to prepare for an online reputation case

Online content can disappear or change at any moment, so secure the evidence before you take any step. Gather:

  • The exact URL of each item of content, which the notice to the platform must state (article 16 of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065)
  • Dated screenshots showing the content, the author or their username, the date of posting and the reactions
  • For the most serious content, a report by a judicial officer, the court officer who can formally record what is online
  • The date you discovered the content, and the date it was first posted if shown
  • Proof that the alleged facts are false: orders, invoices, exchanges with the customer
  • If you suspect a fake review: proof that no order was placed, the account’s history, any link with a competitor or a former employee
  • Notices already sent to the platform and its replies
  • Evidence of the loss: fall in turnover, cancellations, messages from customers

Lawyer or online reputation agency?

Online reputation agencies work on visibility: monitoring, positive content, search rankings. A lawyer works on the law: classifying the statements, sending reasoned notices, going to court. Here is what each can do, with the relevant legal provision:

Lawyer or online reputation agency: what each can do
QuestionOnline reputation agencyLawyerSource
Reporting content to the platformYes: any individual or organisation can use the notice mechanismYes, with the reasoned explanation of illegality that the Regulation requiresRegulation (EU) 2022/2065, art. 16(1) and (2)
Classifying the statements: disparagement, defamation, insultOnly within the limits of the rules on who may give legal adviceYes; the classification determines the legal basis and the time limitLaw of 31 December 1971, art. 54; Law of 29 July 1881, art. 29 and 65
Challenging a platform’s refusalCan use the internal complaint-handling systemThe same, then a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body, or the courtRegulation (EU) 2022/2065, art. 20 and 21
Identifying an anonymous authorNoYes, through a measure ordered by the courtCode of Civil Procedure, art. 145
Obtaining a court order for removal, or damagesNoYes, in urgent interim proceedings or on the meritsCode of Civil Procedure, art. 835 and 873; Civil Code, art. 1240
Publishing positive reviewsYes, through content work, provided it does not use fake reviews, which count as a misleading commercial practiceNot relevantConsumer Code, art. L. 121-4, 28°
Confidentiality and liabilityDepends on its contractProfessional secrecy and compulsory professional liability insuranceLaw of 31 December 1971, art. 27 and 66-5

The two approaches complement each other: removing unlawful content is a legal task, restoring visibility is a communication task.

In online reputation cases, haste and improvisation are expensive: a poorly founded claim can be dismissed, and a clumsy public reply can make the attack worse. A lawyer classifies the statements precisely, picks the most effective legal basis and procedure, meets the deadlines and runs the strategy from start to finish, from removal of the content to compensation.

Removing content hosted by a foreign platform

The Digital Services Act applies to intermediary services offered to users in the EU, wherever the provider is established (article 2(1) of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065). A platform established in Ireland or the United States must therefore offer the notice mechanism described above to anyone, wherever they are based, and give reasons for its decision. A provider established outside the EU that offers services in the EU must appoint a legal representative in a Member State, who can be held liable for breaches of the Regulation (article 13).

If the platform refuses, you can use its internal complaints system and then a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body, and you keep the right to go to court (articles 20 and 21). Against an author or a platform domiciled in an EU Member State, a claim in tort may be brought before the courts of the place where the harmful event occurred or may occur (article 7(2) of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012). A French court may also order provisional measures even where another court has jurisdiction over the merits (article 35).

On the applicable law, defamation and other violations of personality rights fall outside Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (article 1(2)(g)): the governing law is set by the conflict rules of the court hearing the case. Disparagement by a competitor, on the other hand, falls under the rules on unfair competition, which in principle point to the law of the market affected; where it targets only one specific competitor, the law of the country where the damage occurs applies (articles 6(1), 6(2) and 4(1)).

Frequently asked questions on online reputation and defamation

Is an insult the same as defamation?

No. Defamation means alleging or attributing a fact that harms a person's honour or reputation. An insult is any offensive expression, term of contempt or invective that does not attribute any fact (article 29 of the Law of 29 July 1881). Both fall under the same law and are time-barred after three months (article 65). The difference therefore depends on whether the statements contain a specific fact, and it must be settled before acting: the document that starts the proceedings must classify the statements and state the applicable provision (article 53).

Can the author of an anonymous review be identified?

Often, yes, through a court order. Where there is a legitimate reason to preserve or establish, before any trial, evidence of facts on which the outcome of a dispute may depend, the court may order any legally permitted investigative measure, either on an application made without notice to the other side or in urgent interim proceedings (article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure). This route is commonly used to obtain from a platform the data that identifies the author of content. Act quickly, and bear in mind the three-month time limit for defamation (article 65 of the Law of 29 July 1881).

Can a former employee or a competitor be held liable?

Yes. French courts have already ruled against a former employee who posted a very negative review of their former employer, and against a competitor spreading disparaging statements. Freedom to criticise has limits: once statements go beyond mere opinion and unfairly discredit a business, their author can be held liable.

Do I need to act quickly?

Yes, for two reasons. First, the content keeps causing harm for as long as it stays online; urgent interim proceedings can get it removed quickly. Second, the legal category chosen determines the deadline: only three months for defamation (article 65 of the Law of 29 July 1881). Take advice without delay to protect your rights.

Related topics

Maître Léa Scemama

Written by Maître Léa Scemama, member of the Paris Bar, Miraï Avocats. This page sets out the law as it stood on the date it was last updated. It is general information, not advice on your particular situation.

Updated on

Contact

Is your business under attack online?

Maître Léa Scemama reviews the content, takes the steps to have it removed and acts for your business to obtain compensation. Court documents and hearings are in French; she explains each step to you in English.