Skip to content
MIRAÏAvocats

Real Estate Law

Property dispute lawyer in France: act before time runs out

Hidden defects after a purchase, faulty building work, tenancy and co-ownership disputes: we represent property owners before the French civil and administrative courts, and explain each step in English.

Call
Contents

If you own property in France and a dispute breaks out, three questions come before the merits: which time limit is still running, what evidence the court will accept, and which court to go to. In France, a strong case brought too late is lost. Maître Léa Scemama, a member of the Paris Bar, settles these three points before bringing the claim: first through urgent interim proceedings when the situation demands it, then in a full trial. She works in English and can run your case remotely, by video call and with documents signed electronically. Hearings and court documents are in French, and she explains each step to you in English. The firm acts in Paris and the Île-de-France region, and advises throughout France.

Maître Léa Scemama represents clients before every court that may hear a property case: the Civil Court, the Court of Appeal and the administrative courts. She acts at every stage, including urgent applications to the interim relief judge, the judge who can order fast, provisional measures before a full trial.

See all our real estate law services.

How we help in a property dispute

How we help in a property dispute
Your situationWhat we doWhat you get
A dispute has just arisenWe identify the legal basis for your claim, the time you have left and the right courtA strategy note with the deadline you must not miss
A deadline is approachingWe issue proceedings straight away and keep negotiating in parallelYour rights protected by a step that stops the clock
A defect is disputedUrgent application for a court-appointed expert, follow-up of the expert's work, written technical submissionsA court expert's report, the basis for any compensation
An urgent situationUrgent interim application to stop a clearly unlawful nuisance or prevent imminent damageA fast, enforceable decision
A settlement attempt is compulsory before going to courtWe run the required attempt and make sure your claim can be heardA claim the court will accept, with no time lost

How we charge is explained on our fees page.

Time limits for property claims

This is the first document we prepare in any property case. Choosing the wrong legal basis can mean relying on a time limit that has already run out.

Time limits for property claims in France and when they start
ClaimTime limitStarts from
Warranty against hidden defects2 years, and 20 years at most in any eventDiscovery of the defect; the 20-year long-stop runs from the sale
One-year completion guarantee1 yearAcceptance of the works
Two-year guarantee on equipment2 yearsAcceptance of the works
Ten-year (decennial) guarantee10 yearsAcceptance of the works
Intermediate defects and non-conformities, article 1792-4-310 yearsAcceptance of the works
Claims under a residential lease, article 7-1 of the Act of 6 July 19893 yearsThe day the person entitled knew or should have known the facts
Claims under the commercial lease rules, article L145-602 yearsThe day the person entitled knew or should have known the facts
Annulment of a co-ownership general meeting resolution, article 422 monthsNotification of the minutes

For the substance of each area, see our pages on construction defects, residential leases, commercial leases and co-ownership.

Construction guarantees

Under the ten-year liability rule (Article 1792 of the Civil Code), any builder is liable without proof of fault, for ten years from acceptance of the works, for defects that undermine the soundness of the building or make it unfit for its purpose. Acceptance is the formal handover at which the owner takes delivery of the works. The firm brings claims against the builders, architects and project managers responsible, arranges court-ordered expert assessments and obtains judgments ordering repair or reinstatement.

On top of ten-year liability, the builder owes the one-year completion guarantee, which covers every defect reported at acceptance or in the following year, and the two-year guarantee on equipment that can be removed without damaging the structure. The firm enforces these guarantees and deals with the building insurers.

Tenancy disputes

Disputes between landlords and tenants are also part of our property litigation work.

The eviction procedure itself, from the payment demand served by a judicial officer to the enforcement of the eviction order, is explained step by step on our page on tenant eviction.

Co-ownership disputes

We also act in disputes within buildings held in co-ownership, between owners, the co-owners' association and the managing agent.

What stops the clock in a property dispute, and what does not

This is where most mistakes are made, and they are the most expensive ones. To work out your own deadline, use our French limitation period calculator.

  • A formal notice does not stop the limitation period, even when sent by recorded delivery with proof of receipt.
  • An informal expert assessment arranged by an insurer does not stop it either, and every month of drawn-out discussion uses up your time.
  • A court claim, even an urgent interim application, stops both the ordinary limitation period and the stricter time bars, under article 2241 of the Civil Code. This is the step that protects your rights.

Trying to settle before going to court: when it is compulsory

Article 750-1 of the Code of Civil Procedure requires a prior attempt at conciliation, mediation or a participatory procedure (a negotiation in which each party is assisted by its lawyer) in two situations that often arise in property matters: when the claim is for a sum of €5,000 or less, and when the dispute concerns an abnormal nuisance between neighbours or one of the neighbour claims listed in the text, such as fixing boundaries or the distance of plantings from the boundary. Otherwise the claim is inadmissible, and the court can raise this on its own initiative.

There are exemptions, in particular urgency, an application to have an agreement approved by the court, or the lack of an available conciliator within a reasonable time. Whether to make the attempt or rely on an exemption depends on the facts of the case, because an inadmissible claim costs months.

Urgent interim applications and court-appointed experts in property cases

The interim relief judge can act before any full trial, on four separate grounds that must not be confused.

  • Expert evidence before a trial. Under article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure, before any trial, to secure evidence of facts on which the outcome of a dispute may depend. This is the usual way to have a defect recorded and its nature established.
  • Urgency. To order measures that cannot seriously be contested.
  • A clearly unlawful nuisance or imminent damage. To stop irregular works, an encroachment or a dangerous situation at once.
  • An interim payment. Where the debt cannot seriously be disputed (article 835 of the Code of Civil Procedure), for example the refund of an immobilisation fee after a loan refusal that meets the terms of the preliminary sale agreement.

When the court orders an expert assessment, the claimant pays the deposit the court sets in advance, and that amount is later charged to the party found liable. The documents to bring to the first meeting are always the same: the contract and its schedules, the reports, all correspondence, dated photographs, invoices and insurance certificates.

The interim relief judge can act quickly to order protective or investigative measures, such as a court-ordered expert assessment, before any full proceedings have even started. In property cases, urgent interim relief is often used to stop unlawful works immediately, order temporary repairs to damaged property, appoint a court expert to record defects or assess the loss, or order the parties to disclose documents. The firm regularly handles these urgent procedures and acts quickly.

Hidden defects in a property you bought: what has changed

If the property you bought has a serious defect that was not visible and existed before the sale, you have two years from discovering it to bring a claim. Since the judgments of the mixed chamber of the Court of Cassation of 21 July 2023, that period also sits within an overall long-stop of twenty years from the sale. For a property bought long ago, this second limit can bar the claim even though the defect has only just come to light.

The clause excluding this warranty, common in French deeds of sale, does not apply if the seller is a professional or knew of the defect. It does, however, remain valid between professionals working in the same field.

The warranty against hidden defects (Articles 1641 to 1649 of the Civil Code) protects buyers against defects that were not visible and that make the property unfit for its intended use, or reduce that use so much that the buyer would not have bought it, or would have paid less. The claim must be brought within two years of discovering the defect. The firm assesses whether the claim is sound, arranges expert assessments (informal or court-ordered) and represents buyers seeking to cancel the sale or obtain a price reduction.

Costs and timeframes for a property dispute

Rough figures for a typical property dispute, from the settlement attempt to the judgment. The time limits for bringing a claim are in the table above; the durations below are how long each procedure takes.

Cost and duration of each stage of a property dispute
StepCosts to expectRealistic timeframeOur fees
Settlement attempt before going to courtConciliation by a court conciliator, a volunteer appointed by the courts: in practice free of charge. Mediation: the mediator's fee, agreed with the partiesIn practice, a few weeks to a few monthsTime spent, at €300 excluding VAT per hour
Urgent application for a court-appointed expertA summons served by a judicial officer, the court officer who serves documents and enforces judgments, then a deposit set by the court and paid in advance by the party it names, in practice usually the claimant (article 269 of the Code of Civil Procedure)In practice, a few weeks to obtain the orderFixed fee of €2,500 to €3,500 excluding VAT
The court expert's workThe court may order a further deposit if the first one is not enough (article 280 of the Code of Civil Procedure), and you pay the fees of any technical adviser who assists youThe period the court gives the expert when appointing them (article 265 of the same code); in practice, often several monthsFixed fee of €2,500 to €4,000 excluding VAT
Full proceedings on the meritsA summons served by a judicial officer, then the court costs of the proceedingsIn practice, from several months to over a year at first instanceFixed fee of €3,500 to €5,000 excluding VAT

Court costs, which include the court expert's fees, are paid by the losing party (articles 695 and 696 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Your own legal fees are not included, but the court may order the other party to pay you a sum towards them (article 700 of the same code).

Documents you need for a property dispute

Whoever claims that an obligation must be performed has to prove it (article 1353 of the Civil Code), and in a property dispute the date the defects appeared also decides the time limit for acting. Gather these from the start:

  • The deed of sale or the lease, with its schedules and surveys
  • The works contracts and quotes, and the acceptance report (the record of the handover of the works) with any reservations noted
  • The insurance certificates of everyone involved in the works, in particular building damage insurance and ten-year liability insurance
  • Reports drawn up by a judicial officer recording the defects, and dated photographs
  • Any expert reports already drawn up informally or for an insurer
  • Quotes and invoices for repair or protective works
  • Letters, formal notices and the other party's replies, in date order
  • In a building held in co-ownership, the general meeting minutes and proof that they were notified

Property dispute: conciliator, mediator or lawyer?

Trying to settle first does not mean choosing between a neutral third party and a lawyer: both often play a part in the same case, at different times. What each one can do, with the legal source:

Conciliator or mediator, and lawyer: what each can do
QuestionCourt conciliator or mediatorLawyerSource
RoleAn impartial third party helps the parties reach an agreement themselves, without deciding the disputeAdvises one party, defends its interests and assists it both in negotiation and in courtCode of Civil Procedure, art. 1530 and 1530-3; Act No 71-1130 of 31 December 1971, art. 4 and 54
Compulsory settlement attemptAn attempt at conciliation or mediation satisfies the requirement, so the claim can be heardA participatory procedure run by the parties' lawyers satisfies it tooCode of Civil Procedure, art. 750-1
ConfidentialityUnless the parties agree otherwise, what is said, written or done during a conciliation led by a court conciliator or during a mediation is confidentialExchanges between lawyer and client, and between lawyers, are protected by professional secrecyCode of Civil Procedure, art. 1528-3; Act No 71-1130 of 31 December 1971, art. 66-5
Effect on time limitsThe limitation period is suspended from the day the parties agree to use mediation or conciliationA court claim, even an urgent interim application, stops both limitation periods and strict time barsCivil Code, art. 2238 and 2241
Making the agreement bindingAny party may ask the court to approve the agreement reached through conciliation or mediation, which makes it enforceableDrafts the agreement and applies for its approval or, where it is recorded in a deed countersigned by each party's lawyer, asks the court office to stamp it with the enforcement formula that makes it enforceableCode of Civil Procedure, art. 1543 and 1546
Court-appointed expert or urgent measuresNo, only the court can order theseApplies to the interim relief judge to obtain an expert, prevent imminent damage or stop a clearly unlawful nuisanceCode of Civil Procedure, art. 145 and 835

Once a case is before the court, the judge may still, with the parties' agreement and even in interim proceedings, appoint a court conciliator or order mediation (article 1534 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Settlement therefore remains possible throughout the proceedings.

Property litigation draws on civil law, construction law and procedure, with limitation periods and time bars that can defeat a claim brought too late. A lawyer chooses the right legal basis, builds the evidence, takes the case to the right court and defends your interests, both in negotiation and in court, including in urgent interim proceedings where needed.

Owning property in France from abroad: when a dispute arises

If you own property in France and live abroad, a dispute over property rights in it, such as ownership, boundaries or rights of way, or over a tenancy of it, can only be heard by the French courts, wherever the parties live (article 24, point 1, of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012). In these property matters, French law gives jurisdiction to the court for the place where the property is located (article 44 of the Code of Civil Procedure).

Other claims, for example against a seller or a builder, follow the ordinary rules: the courts where the defendant lives (article 4 of the Regulation) or, for a contract, the courts of the place where it is performed (article 7, point 1). Against a French seller or a French builder, both lead to a French court.

Living abroad gives you two extra months for some procedural deadlines, such as the time to appeal (article 643 of the Code of Civil Procedure). It does not extend the time limits for bringing the claim in the first place, set out in the table above. In practice, you do not need to travel for the expert process: the firm attends the expert’s meetings and submits written observations on your behalf, and reports to you in English.

Frequently asked questions about property litigation

Does mediation or conciliation pause the time limits for going to court?

For the limitation period, yes. It is suspended from the day on which, once the dispute has arisen, the parties agree to use mediation or conciliation or, if there is no written agreement, from the day of the first meeting. It starts running again, for at least six months, when the attempt is declared over (article 2238 of the Civil Code). Strict time bars are not covered by this rule unless a text says otherwise (article 2220), so a court claim, even an urgent interim application, remains the way to stop them (article 2241).

How long does a property dispute take in France?

The expert assessment is often the longest stage. The decision ordering it sets the period within which the expert must report (article 265 of the Code of Civil Procedure), and in practice the real argument on the merits starts once the report has been filed. The table of costs and timeframes above gives rough figures for each stage.

Can I appeal against the judgment?

Yes, within one month of notification of the judgment (articles 528 and 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure), or fifteen days for an interim order (article 490). Before the Court of Appeal, you must be represented by a lawyer (article 899). As a rule, an appeal does not stop the judgment being enforced, because it is automatically enforceable straight away (article 514).

When should I apply to the interim relief judge?

When urgency, imminent damage or a clearly unlawful nuisance justifies it, and whenever an expert assessment needs to be ordered before any trial under article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Who pays the court-appointed expert up front?

The claimant deposits the amount set by the court. Once the party responsible has been identified, that cost is charged to them, and it forms part of the loss claimed.

Related services

Maître Léa Scemama

Written by Maître Léa Scemama, member of the Paris Bar, Miraï Avocats. This page sets out the law as it stood on the date it was last updated. It is general information, not advice on your particular situation.

Updated on

Contact

A property dispute?

Maître Léa Scemama will review your case, check which time limits are running and represent you before the French courts. She works in English and can handle your case remotely if you live abroad.